Featuring :
Rod Stewart, Carole King, Aretha Franklin, Maxine Brown & She & Him
The news is out.
All over town.
Your True love has been seen runnin’ around with someone new.
And, don’t some of your, ‘Friends’ love to tell you so!
They’ll tell you, with a theatrical sigh, that you’ve been led on.
They’ll shake their heads and say you’ve been told big, black Lies.
Even your Mama, trying to protect you, will counsel you beware – consider that there might be truth in those ugly rumours.
But. You have Faith.
Faith.
Whatever they say, whatever their motive, You Know.
You Know.
You don’t believe a single word is true.
Not a single word.
Your Love is not like the others.
Not at all.
Oh, no, not my sweet baby.
Oh, no, not my sweet baby.
My sweet baby.
From the heart and soul of Carole King and Gerry Goffin another guaranteed Pop/Soul classic from 1964.
The song was first given to The Shirelles who recorded a version with alternating lead vocals.
Scepter/Wand Reciords Exec Stan Greenberg thought that their version didn’t work because the beauty of the melody and poignancy of the song was obscured by the multiplicity of voices.
But, there was nothing wrong with the backing track so he called up Maxine Brown and told her to take away The Shirelles version and come back with a Hit!
Maxine, listened over and over and as she did she noticed that a group of young girls playing a skipping game outside her apartment had zeroed in on the hook as they skipped and sang ;
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
So, into the studio to overdub her tender, truthful vocal ( with Dee Dee Warwick helping out on the chorus) and Voila!
A sure fire Hit!
Seven weeks on the Billboard Top 40.
Now, the thing about Carole King melodies is that they enter your dreams.
They seem to be contain echoes of half remembered lullabies from your cradle days.
They are both fresh and familiar at first and thousandth hearing.
And, if you are a singer in want of a killer ballad (as singers always are) you inevitably turn to the Goffin/King Songbook because their songs rooted in universal emotions can never go out of style.
Never.
When it comes to singing a killer ballad The Jukebox will brook no argument that Rod Stewart in his early 70’s pomp with The Faces was absolutely as good as it got.
Ronnie Wood providing the tasty guitar licks.
Ian McLagan, Kenney Jones and above all Ronnie Lane providing the rugged but oh so right Rock ‘n’ Roll/Soul musical mash up.
Rod, of course, knew that when it came to breaking hearts there millions practiced in the art.
Yet, he brings total conviction to the lover’s cri de couer :
Not my baby, not my baby, not my baby, Oh, No, Not My Baby!
Rod, in those days had sensitivity as well as swagger.
I’m sure that the music press of those times would have described Rod as a, ‘Rock God’ along with Robert Plant and several other extravagantly maned stage strutters.
But, when it came to the Soul arena there was only ever one Queen.
Aretha Franklin.
The key word here is Faith.
Incarnating on record and in performance the attractions of the flesh and faith and giving each realm its proper due was Aretha’s special gift.
Whatever she sang she sang with a Believer’s passion.
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
Alongside the majestic vocal listen to the testifying of Cornell Dupree and Eddie Hinton on Guitar, Barry Beckett on Keyboards, David Hood on Bass and Roger Hawkins on Drums.
Not my baby, not my baby, not my baby, Oh, No, Not My Baby!
Now tell me you don’t Believe!
Remember the mantra, ‘A Goffin/King song never goes out of style’?
Well, from just a few years ago here’s the proof.
Music chameleon M Ward and Actor/Singer Zooey Deschanel are together ‘She & Him’.
Embed from Getty Images*
Embed from Getty ImagesAnd together on their CD, ‘Classics’ they have recorded an utterly charming version of, ‘Oh, No, Not My Baby’.
Well, you might have had a last minute fling
But In am sure it didn’t mean a thing
‘Cause yesterday you gave me your ring
And I’m so glad I kept right on saying :
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
To conclude let’s go back to the Source.
Carole King at the piano slaying us all with a deep heart’s core take on her own masterpiece :
Wonderful the first time you hear it and wonderful as long as people can say, with Hope and Faith to all the doubters :
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
Oh, no, not my baby
Oh, no, not my sweet baby
A tear jerker for sure. Aretha will always be a stupendous listen no matter where or when she is heard. Carol Kings version is a hundered times better than the Rod one … in my opinion.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Carol gets my vote too! Lots more of her songs and performances will feature here later. Regards Thom.
LikeLike
Thanks so much for doing this comparison. I had not heard several of these renditions, and it would definitely be hard to choose my absolute favorite. I enjoyed Maxine Brown’s era classic, and the funky new spin She & Him played. Rod Stewart is always a rock star of his own right. However, I’d have to give the edge to Aretha Franklin, I believe. After all, She is the Queen of Soul; yet, I was thinking that thought, and at the same moment, scrolled down to realize I hadn’t listened to Carole King. Hold up. Stop the band. The bluesy, heart-wrenching chords coming from her being pulled on my heart, and now, I have a tie! It’s funny how, upon first listen to the other artists, I didn’t think I’d ever heard this song. Then, as Carole King’s voice rang out, I realized this is one of those songs I’ve heard through the years while strolling through the mall, or eating at a romantic restaurant, and I’d find myself swaying to the music, never really identifying the artist or the melody. It was as if, as soon as the video sound began, my heart, my mind and my soul met up and said, “Ahh, there you are!” … thanks for the music history lesson, and thanks for helping me discover the song I’ve truly loved for ages. 💕
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks very much. Welcome to The Jukebox. Hope you’ll find much to enjoy here (several other Carole King songs featured). Regards Thom.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am personally very fond of the Dusty Springfield version, although the She & Him version is the highlight of that particular album.
LikeLiked by 2 people
WK – I am very fond of Dusty’s takes too. There will be a dedicated post on her great career here later. Regards Thom.
LikeLiked by 1 person